Look beyond ordinary analysis
After talking to many day traders I notice that most of them discount the Commitments of Traders report as a functional leading indicator. They are of the opinion that the data reported lags five days hence is invalid.
But this is the big one.
Commitments of Traders is first of 4 essential Steps to profit in Forex. It confirms your long term bias in the market.
There is no better tangible way of doing so.
If you are that guy who always says – Commitments of Traders is invalid, late, old or irrelevant, perhaps this article is not for you.
This article is for those traders who can see beyond 15 minute charts, but I hope that you decide to read it anyway because
I truly believe there is enough evidence for you to change your mind and once you get to the bottom of this page, you will be a much better trader.
Price is a result of buyers’ and sellers’ interaction. Many traders know about it, but just a few use it.
The practical application of this comprehensive market law can be extremely useful for anyone who has ever dared to predict future prices.
Fundamental and technical conditions create supply and demand. This is the only law of the price.
No matter how trivial it may seem, demand and supply determine the price.
It might be partly driven by emotions or rationale but after all – the volume of orders will decide which way the price will go.
Supply and demand is a basic principle in economics illustrated in the chart below.
The higher the price (Y axis) the less the commodity is demanded (X axis).
There are many ways to measure supply and demand in the market. But Commitments of Traders is by far the most accurate tool I know.
The method of the market analysis using the Commitments of Traders Report can be considered as fundamental analysis.
Fundamental analysis itself hasn’t found a wide application for traders. It’s no secret that most traders use technical analysis for the real trading.
Why is that?
This is due to the fact that fundamental analysis is often connected with the economic news release, and it’s impossible to predict the market reaction to the news because traders have limited knowledge of finance and macroeconomics. Many traders default to technical analysis as a core of their trading.
DON’T BE ONE OF THOSE GUYS!
One cannot sustain profits in the long run without understanding the real forces behind the price movement.
The Commitments of Traders Report is issued by CFTC.
The Commitments of Traders (COT) report provides a breakdown of each Tuesday’s open interest for markets in which 20 or more traders hold positions equal to or above the reporting levels established by the CFTC. This is an essential tool for gauging long term sentiment in futures markets.
Antecedents of the Commitments of Traders (COT) reports can be traced all the way back to 1924. In that year, the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Grain Futures Administration (predecessor to the USDA Commodity Exchange Authority, in turn the predecessor to the CFTC), published its first comprehensive annual report of hedging and speculation in regulated futures markets.
Beginning as of June 30, 1962, COT data was published each month. At the time, this report for 13 agricultural commodities was proclaimed as “another step forward in the policy of providing the public with current and basic data on futures market operations.” Those original reports then were compiled on an end-of-month basis and published on the 11th or 12th calendar day of the following month.
It reports all open positions in futures markets of three main groups of traders:
The report breaks down each Tuesday’s Open Interest and gives us a powerful view on what exactly the big guys have been doing in the marketplace and what their plans might be.
It is issued every Friday and includes data from Tuesday to Tuesday.
The three days prior to the release date are not included.
Simply put, COT reports give us a view into the trading books of the most influential traders in the market.
Once we know what these guys are doing, it is easier to eliminate the noise, opinions and hype. Remember, the volume of money placed on one side of the market will tip the price towards that direction. This is supply and demand in play. This is as simple as it gets.
Reports are available in both a short and long format. The short report shows an open interest separately for reportable and nonreportable positions.
For reportable positions, additional data is provided for commercial and non-commercial holdings, spreading, changes from the previous report, percents of an open interest by category, and numbers of traders. Most of it is irrelevant to us.
We want to focus on Commercial, Non-Commercial orders and open interest.
The CFTC makes available more than three years of history of disaggregated data included in the weekly Commitments of Traders (COT) reports.
You can access the Historical Viewable table and in the excel format by going into left hand side panel on the website as per screenshot below.
This could be handy if you want to see more correlations between the price and C.O.T data.
When an individual reportable trader is identified to the Commission, the trader is classified either as “commercial” or “non-commercial.” All of a trader’s reported futures positions in a commodity are classified as commercial if the trader uses futures contracts in that particular commodity for hedging as defined in CFTC Regulation 1.3, 17 CFR 1.3(z).
Regulations define who is who based on the trading activity they commence. Some of the traders or institutions would be exempt from taxation ( hedging only ) other would have to disclose books etc.
The most important fact is, these two groups HAVE TO CARRY OUT A LOT OF TRADING for CFTC to consider them in the report.
These guys are heavy duty with plenty of capital behind them. The smallest contract they allow to trade is €125,000.
On principle, they know what they doing more often than the retail trader like me or you.
There are a few important definitions to grasp in order to fully understand this concept.
This is very important concept for futures traders.
Open Interest is the total number of outstanding contracts that are held by market participants at the end of each day.
Increasing open interest means that new money is flowing into the marketplace. Traders open new positions and create a new transactions. The result will be that the present trend ( up, down or sideways) will continue.
Declining open interest means that the market is liquidating and implies that the prevailing price trend is coming to an end.
See more smart resources if you want to learn more about Open Interest
See this simple table to analyse open interest
A trading entity generally gets classified as a “commercial” trader by filing a statement with the Commission, on CFTC Form 40: Statement of Reporting Trader, that it is commercially “…engaged in business activities hedged by the use of the futures or option markets.”
This group of traders are called hedgers or producers. Depending on the market, this group would include mainly large producers of a given commodity or financial institutions that hedge against future price changes.
For example: Gold Mine, Sugar factory, wheat producers, Nestle (sugar is their main raw material) etc.
On principle these guys want to sell their produce in the market at a high price and buy it back at the lowest price possible. This is why Commercial traders are most bullish at the bottom of the market and most bearish at the top.
See how Commercial traders (in red) were positioned at the multi year extreme levels of their orders. The price reversed right after to begin a new, long term trend.
The buyers of goods and the risks attendant to them are called speculators. The main objective of a speculator is to generate profit from the difference between the current and future prices.
They provide high market liquidity.
Large banks, investment and hedge funds would be included in this section.
These guys manage money for their clients and are highly profit driven. They are trend followers and would be most bullish at the end of the bull market and most bearish at the end of a bear market.
See how Speculative positions (in green) are positioned at the extreme levels right before the market turns.
The long and short open interest shown as “Non-reportable Positions” is derived by subtracting total long and short “Reportable Positions” from the total open interest. Accordingly, for “Non-reportable Positions,” the number of traders involved and the commercial/non-commercial classification of each trader are unknown. CFTC
Essentially, whoever is left after classification goes into this group. This section includes small, retail traders like me and you. We are not eligible to report our trading positions to CFTC. They don’t give a tiny rat’s ass about our trading.
Retail open positions do not move the markets
We have no impact on the market prices. This group is a “heard” and it is on the wrong side of the market in most cases. It should be used as a contrarian indicator.
Finding the report is a fairly easy task.
Follow the step below to access the Commitments of Traders report.
Go to http://www.cftc.gov/index.htm and choose Commitments of Traders from the Market Report tab in the main menu
Scroll down to CURRENT LEGACY REPORTS section and choose “Short format” report next to Chicago Mercantile Exchange
Once clicked in, you will see a basic page with many instruments. This is where CFTC reports data on major markets including: commodities, currencies, indices.
Here you will find butter, cattle, British Pound, Eurodollars or S&P 500 futures.
We are after the major currencies. These are our favorite!
Each market is being given a table. All relevant information is included in that table.
The data is published every Friday but compiled up to the previous Tuesday.
For example, there will be new set of figures published this Friday 20th May. The data will be compiled for a week 10th-17th May and so on.
This is important especially when important news is due to be released. Sometimes the COT report will not include them until the week after.
COT report is not designed as a market entry tool.
The market can be short term bullish in a long term downtrend.
The report is designed to gauge supply and demand of important market participants.
It can be used to confirm mid/long term fundamental bias in a given market.
Decrease/flat non-commercial long positions on rising prices might suggest the top is imminent. Traders should seek a short setup near the resistance.
Increase in short non-commercial positions on falling prices might support the downtrend.
Depending on the trader, one of the groups might be analysed. Some traders will look into Hedgers behaviour and analyse their positioning in the market. Some are of the opinion that these guys
are the biggest in the market hence know the market best.
Other traders would analyse Speculative positioning. Personally, I like to look at both groups open interest. In most cases, they would be exactly opposite anyway.
There are two main techniques you might use for your trading.
Extreme levels swings
There is a strong correlation between multiyear high or low positions and market swings.
On the chart below we analyse EURUSD and EURO FX Commitments of Traders data.
On the chart below you see that Commercial traders (in red) were at multiyear low or high levels right before the price topped and reversed. The rule is to wait for the highest or lowest level in 3 years to “start to think” (didn’t say “to enter”) of long term reversal. Remember, Commitments of Traders is not a market entry tool.
Commitments of Traders will indicate the current trend is about to end but it is still likely to carry on for a little while. We don’t know if this is 100 or 500 pips. As the market’s participation grows over time it might be difficult to predict the top or bottom. There could always be more traders in the market this year than they were last year.
The entry must be determined by using other technical price action signals. These could be candlestick reversal pattern on daily or weekly charts, double top/bottoms, divergences and more.
These will vary from the market to market and should be chosen individually based on the trader’s preference.
Personally, I find the engulfing daily candle very reliable to signal the end of the current trend.
This is my favourite technique. It is more accurate and reliable compared to the extreme levels strategy. It is based on a more tangible principle.
The basic premise of this concept is to “start thinking” about trend change if the Speculative positions turn NET long or NET short.
Speculators will be NET LONG if their long positions exceed short positions. THEY WILL HOLD MORE LONGS ON BALANCE.
On the example below, speculators hold more short positions (123,149) than longs (101,277), hence they are NET SHORT
On the chart below you notice how the Speculators turned bullish or bearish on a few occasions. These are marked with the horizontal red line. Every time, the price reversed and followed
the supply or demand law. If the speculators turned NET LONG, the price climbed substantially. The same is true for bear markets. Once Speculators turned NET SHORT, the price quickly flowed
to the downside. Again, this is not an entry tool. Market entry should be determined by using other technical indicators to decrease the risk.
If you are using MT4, there are number of indicators to choose from. The simplest way is to google “commitments of traders mt4”.
I personally use http://www.cot4metatrader.com/. This is a very reliable and cheap ($10 per month) solution.
I get an email every Friday after NY close with the file to be uploaded to my MT4 folder. The data for all major currencies is populated right away.
Plus, Lynn is a very nice guy who is always willing to help.
The indicators come with a few options. You can track open interest, total positions or index of each individual group.
This indicator doesn’t generate many signals. There might be less than five signals per year across major FX crosses once they unfold, they are highly reliable and allow the trader to stay in the position for the mid to long term.
Commitment of Traders has proven to be a very powerful tool on many occasions.
See the below articles and watch the signals unfolding many weeks before the price swing.
In most cases, the retail sentiment is on the opposite side of the market – This is you – the guy who is of the opinion that C.O.T is an old data and can’t be used in trading.
See what you think
I don’t remember times when I traded without looking to see what is smart money doing in the markets. I can’t imagine trading without C.O.T.
C.O.T predicted market swings many times before with deadly accuracy.
Some insights to take away
The COT report is not design as a market entry tool. The Market can be short term bullish in a long term downtrend.
The COT report is designed to gauge supply and demand of important market participants.
It can be used to confirm mid/long term fundamental bias in a given market.
It’s not suitable for day traders who enter the market many times a day and take a few pips every time.
Day traders don’t have to have long term bias for their given currency. Trading is performed based on short term fluctuations.
C.O.T. report is designed for traders with longer horizons. Those who plan their trading a few months ahead. Swing traders enter markets a few times a quarter.
The mid to long term bias is very important in this case. Trader must be certain of the long term market direction. He positions his orders accordingly and uses short term fluctuations as an opportunity to add to the portfolio.
This is the only way to survive in this game in the long shot.
Learn how an Elliott Wave Forex trader applies the theory to trading successfully and profitably. These are EXACT price patterns I used for years to steadily grow my trading account while taking minimum risk.
6,720 total views, 19 views today
6,721 total views, 20 views today